HNRK Coverage Corner

On December 8, 2025, Judge Rennie of the Superior Court of Delaware issued a decision in The Cigna Group v. XL Specialty Ins. Co., C.A. No. N23C-03-009, holding that a civil investigative demand (CID), issued by the U.S. Department of Justice in connection with a False Claims Act investigation, constituted a “Claim” under the insured’s E&O policy, triggering coverage for defense costs.

Responding to a government investigation can be a costly proposition.  And the issue of insurance coverage for the resulting attorneys’ fees and other defense expenses is a perennial issue.  ...

This week at the Coverage Corner, we are looking at a recent Seventh Circuit decision that offers guidance on two issues under Indiana law: (1) an excess insurer’s duty to participate in a pre-suit mediation where the underlying policy limits have not yet been exhausted but “would be” exhausted in the event of a settlement; and (2)  whether a party qualified for coverage as an additional insured based on facts outside the underlying complaint.

Background

The insurance coverage dispute in Atlanta Gas Light Company & Southern Company Gas v. Navigators Insurance Company, Case Nos ...