HNRK Coverage Corner

This week at the Coverage Corner, we take a quick look at a recent decision from the Southern District New York in which the Court, following a bench trial, ruled in favor of a policyholder and used the mutual mistake doctrine to reform the policy to provide coverage.

Background

The facts are relatively straightforward.  The policyholder, Systems 2000 Plumbing Service (“Systems 2000”) sought coverage from its primary (Travelers) and excess (GuideOne National) insurers in connection with claims against Systems 2000 arising from a fire at the Manhattan apartment building where ...

Last month, the Second Circuit held that commercial general liability insurers owed no duty to defend or indemnify a retailer of unfinished firearms in underlying “ghost gun” lawsuits because the lawsuits at issue did not allege injuries arising from an “accident” as defined by Texas law and were thus not “occurrences” under the policies.    

Background

In Granite State Insurance Company v. Primary Arms, LLC, the insurance dispute arose from lawsuits by the State of New York and the cities of Buffalo and Rochester against Primary Arms, LLC (“Primary Arms”), a ...